Skip to main content
Comparing Medicare Plans & Tips for Signing Up
Guest Expert: Melinda Caughill, Medicare Expert, i65 Incorporated
Date:
Attendee's Excellent Rating: 95%
Bookmark
Webinar Replay Description

Click Here to Download the Summary Below

 

1. Medicare Enrollment is More Than Picking a Plan

Many clients believe Medicare enrollment is simply choosing a plan from carriers like UnitedHealthcare, Humana, or Aetna. In reality, enrollment involves six steps:

  1. Timing – Deciding when to enroll (age 65 vs. delaying due to employer coverage, HSAs, etc.).
  2. Path – Choosing between Original Medicare or Medicare Advantage.
  3. Plans – Selecting specific carriers and products.
  4. Enrollment – Completing Part A/B enrollment via Social Security.
  5. Adding Coverage – Adding Part D or Medigap.
  6. Annual Review – Reviewing coverage every year.

📖 Reference: Medicare.gov – Getting Started


2. Original Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage

Original Medicare (A + B + Medigap + Part D):

  • National access (Mayo, Cleveland Clinic, etc.).
  • Few prior authorizations.
  • Predictable costs with Medigap.
  • Medigap = “cost insurance,” not health insurance, covering out-of-pocket gaps.

Medicare Advantage (Part C):

  • Private insurance companies manage care.
  • Attractive features: $0 premiums, bundled drug coverage, extras (dental, vision, gym).
  • Risks: narrow networks, high prior authorization rates (50M vs. <400K in Original Medicare, 2023), and higher cost exposure ($4,700–$9,000+ out-of-pocket caps).

📖 Reference: KFF – Medicare Advantage Facts


3. Medigap Policy Considerations

  • Plans are standardized (e.g., Plan G, N, F). Benefits are identical across carriers; only cost structure differs.
  • Plan G is generally best (“greatest”), with N as a secondary option. Plan F is closed to new enrollees and shrinking in value.
  • Premium increases depend on:
    • Risk pool size/health.
    • Medical loss ratios (MLR): ideal range 60–80%.
    • Pricing model: attained age (rises annually with age), issue age (locked at enrollment age), or community rated (flat, but may use disguised increases).

📖 Reference: Medicare.gov – Medigap Policy Choices


4. Part D Drug Plans – What Really Matters

  • Coverage is private, not federal. Formularies vary; not all drugs covered.
  • “Preferred” pharmacies may cost more than standard—always compare.
  • Average premium in 2025 ≈ $46. Plans cluster into low ($0–15) or high ($80+).
  • Out-of-pocket cap = $2,000 in 2025 (per Inflation Reduction Act), but only applies if all prescriptions are covered by the plan.
  • Compare based on the three-legged stool: coverage, cost, and quality (star ratings, prior auths, pharmacy access).

📖 Reference: Medicare.gov – Drug Coverage (Part D)


5. Using Tools: Medicare.gov vs. Hey Mo

  • Medicare.gov Plan Finder is essential but cumbersome: requires repeated manual entry, doesn’t store drugs without a Medicare account, and hides prior authorization info.
  • Hey Mo ($30/year) automates re-checking during open enrollment, tests brand/generic swaps, compares across 20 pharmacies, and flags prior authorizations and GoodRx coupons.

📖 Reference: Medicare.gov – Plan Finder


6. IRMAA (Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount)

  • Applies when MAGI exceeds $106,000 (single) or $212,000 (joint) in 2025.
  • Advisors should plan for IRMAA tiers in retirement income planning.
  • SSA-44 form allows clients to appeal IRMAA after life-changing events (e.g., retirement, work reduction).

📖 Reference: SSA – Medicare IRMAA Appeals


7. Advisor Red Flags & Guidance

  • Clients delaying Medicare without creditable coverage risk permanent penalties.
  • Medicare Advantage often marketed heavily by agents due to 40% higher commissions vs. Medigap; advisors should encourage clients to ask probing questions.
  • Encourage annual Part D reviews—only ~30% of beneficiaries do, yet savings can be thousands (recorded case: $149,000 saved by switching).
  • Retiree health coverage varies widely—must be compared individually against Medigap or Advantage.

📖 Reference: NCOA – Medicare Mistakes


Bottom Line for Financial Advisors:

  • Focus client discussions on timing, path, and annual reviews, not just plan selection.
  • Integrate Medicare costs and IRMAA into broader retirement income and tax planning.
  • Be aware of agent incentives that may bias recommendations toward Advantage.
  • Use tools (Medicare.gov, Hey Mo, or CSG data) to validate plan costs, networks, and quality—not just premiums.

 

Attendees Comments:

A few comments from listeners when they were asked what the learned from the webinar:

Didn't realize that there was underwriting involved when changing from one carrier to another if you'd already selected a Medigap plan/carrier. SO it is vital to also make sure your carrier is a good one with those loss ratios and premium increases.
- Jennifer H.

1) The lack of trust of Medicare's star rating system 2) How to choose a Medigap Policy based on current and future low premium costs 3)Researching health plans through Medicare.gov
- Darin D.

It may be difficult to go from a Medicare Advantage plan to a medigap one if you have health issues. You can compare plans at medicare.gov.
- Stephen F.

LOVE this presenter! Extremely knowledgeable, provided actionable plans, engaging to listen to. Will look into the Hey MOE program as an advisor.
- Erin E.

The departure of insurers from providing Part D coverage.
- Mark Z.

missy@financia…

Thu, 09/18/2025 - 10:43

Comments
A few comments from listeners when they were asked what the learned from the webinar:

Didn't realize that there was underwriting involved when changing from one carrier to another if you'd already selected a Medigap plan/carrier. SO it is vital to also make sure your carrier is a good one with those loss ratios and premium increases.
- Jennifer H.

1) The lack of trust of Medicare's star rating system 2) How to choose a Medigap Policy based on current and future low premium costs 3)Researching health plans through Medicare.gov
- Darin D.

It may be difficult to go from a Medicare Advantage plan to a medigap one if you have health issues. You can compare plans at medicare.gov.
- Stephen F.

LOVE this presenter! Extremely knowledgeable, provided actionable plans, engaging to listen to. Will look into the Hey MOE program as an advisor.
- Erin E.

The departure of insurers from providing Part D coverage.
- Mark Z.
Comparing Medicare Plans & Tips for Signing Up 09-17-2025
Comparing Medicare Plans & Tips for Signing Up Q&A 09-17-2025