Skip to main content
How Healthcare Costs Quietly Erode Retirement Income
83% Rating
Matt RutledgeGuest Expert: Matt Rutledge, Boston College

How Healthcare Costs Quietly Erode Retirement Income

Presenter: Matt Rutledge, Professor of the Practice, Boston College Economics Department, and Research Fellow, Center for Retirement Resea...

Trusted by 1000+ Financial Advisors

Unlock Unlimited Expert Webinars

Get Full Access to 100+ Sessions at $19/month

Subscribe Now

Discussions & Comments

missy@financialexpertsnetwork.com 3 days 14 hours ago
A few comments from listeners when they were asked what the learned from the webinar:

It was fascinating to learn more about the difference in Medigap vs Medicare Advantage, as well as the similarity at the median for those with Med Advantage vs strictly Medicare. - Daniel L.

Out of pocket medical expenses for people in Medicare Advantage Plans wind up being similar to people on traditional Medicare, despite the advantage of $0 premiums for enrollees in Medicare Advantage Plans. - Michael D.

There were a few graphs and results that are helpful & meaningful. The best one was the graph that showed the healthcare costs for retirees using Medicare Advantage vs Original Medicare were basically the same. Very enlightening. - Robert D.

Women who are unhealthy and lower income suffer financial hardships. I would like more webinars on this topic. - Jean Louis T.

Not much difference between Medicare Advantage and traditional in terms of spending. - Angela R.

Advantage plans may not really be an advantage. - Matt A.

Good statistics were provided. - Allen M.

missy@financia…

Thu, 11/12/2026 - 14:09

A few comments from listeners when they were asked what the learned from the webinar:

It was fascinating to learn more about the difference in Medigap vs Medicare Advantage, as well as the similarity at the median for those with Med Advantage vs strictly Medicare. - Daniel L.

Out of pocket medical expenses for people in Medicare Advantage Plans wind up being similar to people on traditional Medicare, despite the advantage of $0 premiums for enrollees in Medicare Advantage Plans. - Michael D.

There were a few graphs and results that are helpful & meaningful. The best one was the graph that showed the healthcare costs for retirees using Medicare Advantage vs Original Medicare were basically the same. Very enlightening. - Robert D.

Women who are unhealthy and lower income suffer financial hardships. I would like more webinars on this topic. - Jean Louis T.

Not much difference between Medicare Advantage and traditional in terms of spending. - Angela R.

Advantage plans may not really be an advantage. - Matt A.

Good statistics were provided. - Allen M.

Click Here to Download Summary Below

How Healthcare Costs Quietly Erode Retirement Income

Presenter: Matt Rutledge, Professor of the Practice, Boston College Economics Department, and Research Fellow, Center for Retirement Research at Boston College
Presented by: Financial Experts Network
Date: November 11, 2026

Webinar Overview

Financial advisors frequently evaluate retirement readiness by examining income replacement ratios, Social Security benefits, investment portfolios, and projected spending. However, these calculations may overlook a significant factor: how much retirement income remains available after healthcare expenses.

In this Financial Experts Network webinar, Matt Rutledge presented research examining how out-of-pocket medical spending reduces retirees' purchasing power, particularly for households that rely heavily on Social Security.

Using data from the Health and Retirement Study, Rutledge and his research colleagues examined the relationship between Social Security benefits, other retirement income, and medical expenses among Medicare beneficiaries age 65 and older.

The findings revealed that healthcare costs consume a substantial portion of retirement income, even among individuals covered by Medicare. The burden is especially pronounced for women, retirees in poor health, and lower-income households without Medicaid coverage.

The central message: Retirement income adequacy should not be measured solely by how much income retirees receive, but by how much remains after paying for necessary healthcare.

1. Measuring Retirement Income After Healthcare Expenses

Traditional retirement planning often evaluates income adequacy using replacement rates, which compare retirement income with earnings before retirement.

Rutledge explained that these measures do not necessarily reflect the income retirees have available for everyday living expenses.

Healthcare spending is particularly important because much of it is nondiscretionary. Retirees cannot easily eliminate prescription medications, necessary medical procedures, or treatment for chronic conditions without potentially compromising their health.

The research therefore examined income remaining after out-of-pocket medical expenses.

What Expenses Were Included?

The study incorporated:

  • Medicare Part B and Part D premiums
  • Medicare Advantage and supplemental insurance premiums
  • Deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance
  • Prescription drug expenses
  • Dental, vision, hearing, and other uncovered medical services
  • Income-related Medicare premium adjustments

Importantly, long-term care expenses were excluded, meaning the findings do not capture the full potential healthcare-related financial burden retirees may experience.

The research focused on community-dwelling Medicare beneficiaries age 65 and older who received Social Security and were not working full time.

Key takeaway: Retirement income projections should account for healthcare expenses before determining how much income is available for housing, food, transportation, and discretionary spending.

2. How Much Social Security Income Remains After Healthcare Costs?

One of the most significant findings from Matt Rutledge's research was how much of retirees' Social Security income is consumed by out-of-pocket healthcare expenses.

For the median household, approximately 29% of Social Security income goes toward healthcare costs, leaving just 71% available for housing, food, transportation, and other living expenses.

However, the financial burden varies considerably among retirees.

Healthcare Spending as a Percentage of Social Security Income

  • Median household: Healthcare expenses consume approximately 29% of Social Security income, leaving 71% for other needs.
  • One-quarter of households: Medical expenses consume more than half of Social Security benefits, leaving less than 50% for other expenses.
  • Households with the greatest financial burden: At the fifth percentile of income remaining after medical spending, healthcare costs consume approximately 98% of Social Security income, leaving just 2% for other needs.

These findings are particularly concerning because Social Security is the primary source of retirement income for many older Americans. Unlike investment income, Social Security provides lifetime benefits with annual cost-of-living adjustments, making it an important foundation of retirement security.

When medical expenses consume a substantial portion of these benefits, retirees may have little financial flexibility to address other essential needs or unexpected expenses.

What Happens When Other Retirement Income Is Included?

The financial picture improves when researchers account for additional income sources, including pensions, retirement-account withdrawals, investment income, and part-time earnings.

For the median household, out-of-pocket healthcare expenses represent approximately 12% of total retirement income, leaving 88% available for other spending.

However, significant disparities remain:

  • Retirees with substantial pensions, investment income, or other resources generally have greater flexibility to absorb medical expenses.
  • Households with limited income beyond Social Security face considerably greater financial pressure.
  • Among households with the highest medical spending burdens relative to income, healthcare expenses consume nearly 60% of total retirement income.

Importantly, these figures do not include long-term care expenses, which could create additional financial challenges for retirees who eventually require assisted living, nursing home care, or other extended services.

Why These Findings Matter for Financial Advisors

Rutledge emphasized that traditional retirement income replacement ratios may overstate retirees' actual spending power because they do not adequately account for necessary medical expenses.

For example, a retiree receiving $3,000 per month in Social Security benefits who spends 29% of that amount on healthcare would have approximately $2,130 remaining for other expenses.

That difference can significantly affect the retiree's ability to maintain their standard of living, particularly when housing, food, transportation, and other essential costs continue to rise.

Advisors should therefore evaluate retirement income not simply in terms of gross benefits, but also in terms of the income remaining after healthcare expenses.

Key takeaway: Social Security benefits may appear sufficient on paper, but healthcare costs can substantially reduce their purchasing power. Incorporating realistic medical spending assumptions into retirement projections can help advisors identify potential income shortfalls and develop more resilient financial plans.

3. Why Healthcare Spending Remains a Persistent Challenge

Rutledge examined changes in retiree healthcare expenses across the 2018, 2020, and 2022 Health and Retirement Study waves.

Despite significant changes in healthcare policy and insurance coverage, the results remained remarkably consistent.

The presentation reviewed several developments that have influenced retiree healthcare spending.

Declining Employer-Sponsored Retiree Health Coverage

Employer-sponsored retiree health benefits have become substantially less common over recent decades.

As employers reduced these benefits, retirees became increasingly dependent on Medicare and individually purchased supplemental coverage.

Expansion of Medicare Part D

Medicare Part D, introduced in 2006, significantly expanded prescription drug coverage.

The Affordable Care Act subsequently phased out the original Part D coverage gap, commonly known as the donut hole.

Growth of Medicare Advantage

Medicare Advantage enrollment expanded substantially, with many plans offering additional benefits and low or zero supplemental premiums.

However, the research did not identify a substantial improvement in the share of income remaining after healthcare expenses among Medicare Advantage enrollees compared with the Medicare-only category in the study.

Prescription Drug Cost Reforms

The Inflation Reduction Act introduced several changes, including insulin cost-sharing limits, expanded assistance for eligible beneficiaries, and a Part D annual out-of-pocket spending cap beginning in 2025.

Rutledge noted that the latest research data ended in 2022, meaning the study could not yet evaluate the full effects of these newer provisions.

He also emphasized that prescription drugs represent only one component of healthcare spending. Hospitalizations, physician services, premiums, and uncovered care can continue to impose substantial costs.

Key takeaway: Although Medicare coverage and prescription drug protections have improved, the research found little change in the overall medical spending burden through 2022.

4. Which Retirees Face the Greatest Financial Burden?

The research identified several groups that experience disproportionately high healthcare expenses relative to their retirement income.

Women

Women generally retained a smaller percentage of income after medical expenses than men.

Rutledge noted that longer life expectancy may contribute to this difference, although the study did not establish longevity as the sole explanation.

Retirees in Poor Health

Individuals with chronic medical conditions or limitations in activities of daily living faced greater healthcare burdens, particularly when measured against total retirement income.

These individuals may require ongoing treatment, medications, and medical services that cannot easily be reduced.

Lower-Income Retirees Without Medicaid

One of the most vulnerable groups consisted of lower-income households that did not qualify for Medicaid.

Among households in the lowest income quintile without Medicaid coverage, out-of-pocket healthcare expenses consumed approximately one-quarter of total household income.

Rutledge emphasized that Medicaid can provide significant financial protection for eligible individuals, but eligibility restrictions leave some lower-income retirees exposed to substantial medical expenses.

Retirees Heavily Dependent on Social Security

Households with limited pension income, investment assets, or retirement savings were particularly vulnerable.

Even moderate healthcare expenses can create financial hardship when Social Security represents nearly all available income.

Key takeaway: Healthcare spending risk is not distributed evenly. Advisors should pay particular attention to clients with limited supplemental income, chronic health conditions, and restricted access to financial assistance.

5. Medicare Advantage Versus Traditional Medicare

One of the webinar's most interesting findings involved comparisons between Medicare Advantage and traditional Medicare.

Despite the growth of Medicare Advantage and its additional benefits, Rutledge's analysis found similar median outcomes for the percentage of retirement income remaining after medical expenses.

The study showed approximately 72% of Social Security income remaining for Medicare Advantage enrollees, compared with approximately 74% for the Medicare-only comparison group.

Rutledge cautioned against interpreting this small difference as evidence that one type of coverage is universally better.

The data also did not separately identify all Medigap enrollees, meaning the Medicare-only comparison group could include individuals with supplemental coverage.

Important Considerations for Advisors

When evaluating Medicare coverage, advisors should consider more than monthly premiums.

Relevant factors include provider networks, prescription drug coverage, out-of-pocket maximums, deductibles, coinsurance, prior authorization requirements, and access to specialists.

The discussion also addressed the potential difficulty of switching from Medicare Advantage to traditional Medicare with Medigap coverage later in retirement.

Depending on state rules and applicable guaranteed-issue protections, individuals may face medical underwriting when applying for Medigap coverage outside protected enrollment periods.

The presenter acknowledged that this issue warrants further research and that his study was not designed to evaluate every aspect of Medicare plan selection.

Key takeaway: A lower premium does not necessarily mean lower overall healthcare costs. Medicare decisions should account for both current expenses and the potential need for more extensive medical care later in retirement.

6. What Could Change Healthcare Spending in the Future?

Rutledge discussed several developments that may affect retirees' financial circumstances.

Prescription drug reforms: Newer Medicare Part D provisions may reduce spending for individuals with significant prescription drug needs. However, the study's data do not yet demonstrate their overall effect.

Medicaid policy changes: Changes in Medicaid eligibility or coverage could increase financial pressure on certain lower-income households. The effects will depend on the specific provisions, implementation, and individuals affected.

Medicare Advantage coverage: Changes in plan benefits, premiums, networks, and reimbursement policies may influence future out-of-pocket spending.

Long-term care: Because the study excluded long-term care expenses, the findings do not capture the potentially substantial costs of assisted living, nursing home care, or other extended care needs.

Rutledge emphasized that additional research will be necessary to determine whether recent policy changes meaningfully improve retirees' purchasing power.

Key takeaway: Advisors should monitor healthcare policy developments while recognizing that future costs remain uncertain and may vary considerably among clients.

7. Questions and Answers From the Webinar

Q: Why are retirees paying so much for healthcare if Medicare covers most medical services?

A: Medicare beneficiaries still pay premiums, deductibles, copayments, coinsurance, and expenses for services that are not covered. Even relatively modest cost-sharing percentages can become substantial when medical bills are large.

Q: Did the research include income-related Medicare premiums, commonly known as IRMAA?

A: Yes. Rutledge explained that the analysis adjusted Medicare Part B premiums for higher-income beneficiaries to account for income-related premium requirements.

Q: Does Medicaid substantially reduce retirees' out-of-pocket healthcare expenses?

A: The research found that Medicaid beneficiaries generally retained a much larger percentage of their limited income after medical expenses. However, eligibility depends on applicable income, asset, and program requirements.

Q: Does Medicare Advantage provide better financial protection than traditional Medicare?

A: The study found broadly similar median outcomes between the groups examined. However, it did not establish that the coverage options are equivalent for every beneficiary, particularly those with substantial medical needs.

Q: Should retirees avoid supplemental insurance if premiums exceed their annual medical expenses?

A: Not necessarily. Rutledge emphasized that insurance provides protection against unpredictable and potentially catastrophic expenses. Its value should not be measured solely by whether annual benefits exceed premiums.

Q: Does the study account for long-term care expenses?

A: No. Long-term care costs were excluded, making this an important limitation when applying the findings to comprehensive retirement planning.

8. Practical Checklist for Financial Advisors

  1. Evaluate retirement income after healthcare expenses. Consider how much income remains for other needs rather than relying exclusively on gross replacement rates.
  2. Include premiums and cost sharing in retirement projections. Account for Medicare premiums, supplemental insurance, prescription drugs, and uncovered services.
  3. Stress-test healthcare spending. Model scenarios involving chronic illness, higher medical expenses, and unexpected hospitalizations.
  4. Identify clients with limited income flexibility. Pay particular attention to households relying heavily on Social Security.
  5. Review Medicare coverage carefully. Compare total costs, provider access, benefits, and potential future coverage limitations.
  6. Consider IRMAA in tax and retirement-income planning. Evaluate how income decisions may affect Medicare premiums.
  7. Assess eligibility for assistance programs. Identify clients who may qualify for Medicaid, Medicare Savings Programs, or prescription drug assistance.
  8. Plan separately for long-term care. Recognize that the research findings do not include this potentially significant expense.
  9. Revisit healthcare assumptions regularly. Update projections as clients' health, coverage, income, and applicable regulations change.

Final Thoughts

Matt Rutledge's research highlights an important limitation of traditional retirement income planning: income that appears adequate before healthcare expenses may provide considerably less financial security afterward.

For the median household in the study, nearly 30% of Social Security income was consumed by out-of-pocket medical expenses. For approximately one-quarter of households, healthcare absorbed more than half of their Social Security benefits.

The findings also demonstrate that Medicare coverage does not eliminate healthcare-related financial risk. Premiums, cost sharing, uncovered services, and unexpected medical needs can meaningfully reduce retirees' ability to pay for other necessities.

For financial advisors, the implications are clear. Healthcare expenses should be incorporated into retirement-income projections, Medicare coverage decisions, liquidity planning, and discussions about financial resilience.

The most important lesson: Retirement security is not determined simply by the amount of income clients receive. It depends on how much purchasing power remains after essential expenses—including healthcare—have been paid.


Research and Additional Resources

This summary is based on the November 11, 2026 Financial Experts Network webinar featuring Matt Rutledge and the research discussed during the presentation. Reported findings reflect the study population and data available through 2022, not all current Medicare beneficiaries. The summary is intended for educational purposes and does not constitute individualized financial, tax, medical, or insurance advice.